Why Classic Ford Mustangs Are Still One of America's Most Popular Collector Cars
1965–1973 Ford Mustang Buying Guide: Values, Collectability & What Buyers Should Know
Few automobiles have captured the hearts of American car enthusiasts quite like the Ford Mustang. Since its introduction in April 1964, the Mustang has become a symbol of American freedom, performance, and automotive history.
More than 60 years later, first-generation Ford Mustangs remain highly recognizable and sought-after vehicles in the classic-car hobby.
From early Mustang Convertibles and iconic Fastbacks to powerful Mach 1 and Boss models, these legendary automobiles offer something for nearly every classic-car enthusiast.
At Thiel Motor Sales Inc. in DeWitt, Iowa, we've specialized in classic, collector, muscle, and unique vehicles for decades. As a third-generation, family-owned dealership established in 1972, we understand the enduring appeal of these American classics.
If you're considering purchasing a vintage Ford Mustang, here's what makes the 1965–1973 models so special and what you should know before buying one.
1. The Birth of an American Legend
The Ford Mustang was officially introduced on April 17, 1964, at the New York World's Fair.
It quickly became one of the most successful automotive introductions in American history.
Originally available as a Hardtop Coupe and Convertible, the Mustang lineup soon expanded to include the sporty 2+2 Fastback.
Its combination of affordable pricing, attractive styling, and available V8 performance helped launch an entirely new category of automobiles: the Pony Car.
The original Mustang generation ran through the 1973 model year, evolving considerably in styling, size, performance, and equipment.
Today, these first-generation Mustangs represent one of the most recognizable periods in American automotive history.
2. Which Classic Ford Mustang Years Are Most Desirable?
While nearly every first-generation Mustang has a dedicated following, certain model years and body styles attract particular attention from collectors.
1965–1966 Ford Mustang: The Original Pony Cars
The 1965 and 1966 Ford Mustangs are favorites among enthusiasts who appreciate the original Mustang design.
Collectors especially enjoy:
289 cubic-inch V8 engines
Classic Mustang Convertibles
Desirable 2+2 Fastback models
Factory air conditioning and power accessories
Deluxe Pony interiors
Manual and automatic transmissions
GT equipment and attractive factory colors
These early Mustangs offer timeless styling, manageable dimensions, and excellent restoration-parts availability.
For many enthusiasts, a well-restored 1965 or 1966 Mustang is the perfect introduction to classic-car ownership.
1967–1968 Ford Mustang: Bigger, Bolder & More Powerful
The 1967 redesign gave the Mustang a wider, more muscular appearance.
The larger body also made room for additional performance options, including big-block V8 power.
Both the Coupe and Fastback remain popular, while Convertibles continue to appeal to enthusiasts who enjoy open-air cruising.
The 1968 Mustang Fastback also gained lasting recognition through its appearance in the movie Bullitt.
1969–1970 Ford Mustang: The Muscle-Car Era
By 1969, the Mustang had evolved into a serious American performance machine.
The introduction of the Mach 1, Boss 302, and Boss 429 helped establish the Mustang as a major force in the muscle-car market.
Collectors appreciate:
Aggressive Fastback styling
Available 351, 390, 428, and other performance V8 engines, depending on year
Mach 1 performance and appearance packages
Boss 302 and Boss 429 heritage
Manual transmissions and desirable factory options
Beautifully restored examples and tasteful performance-oriented builds remain attractive to enthusiasts.
1971–1973 Ford Mustang: The Final First-Generation Models
The 1971 redesign introduced a larger body and distinctive styling.
Mach 1 models, SportsRoof Fastbacks, and Convertibles have developed their own devoted following.
These final first-generation Mustangs can provide an appealing alternative for collectors who appreciate their styling and performance heritage.
3. Mustang Convertible vs. Fastback: Which Is More Collectible?
One of the most common questions buyers ask is whether a classic Mustang Convertible or Fastback is more desirable.
The answer depends on the particular vehicle.
Mustang Convertibles offer the enjoyment of open-air driving and are especially popular for summer cruising, car shows, and weekend outings.
Mustang Fastbacks are appreciated for their aggressive styling and connections to Ford's performance heritage.
Although certain Fastback configurations can command substantial premiums, well-equipped and professionally restored Convertibles can also be highly desirable.
Meanwhile, Mustang Hardtop Coupes offer the classic appearance of the original Pony Car and can provide excellent enjoyment at a more accessible purchase price.
When comparing values, buyers should focus on body style, engine, options, originality, and overall condition rather than assuming one configuration is always worth more.
4. Why Restoration Costs Matter When Buying a Classic Mustang
One of the most important considerations when buying a vintage Mustang is whether to purchase a project vehicle or an already-restored example.
A classic Mustang needing extensive bodywork, rust repair, paint, mechanical rebuilding, and interior restoration can become a major financial commitment.
Consider this hypothetical restoration comparison:
Restoration Expense | Estimated Cost |
|---|
Project Mustang Purchase | $15,000 |
400 Hours of Labor at $150/Hour | $60,000 |
Parts, Paint Materials & Outside Services | $20,000 |
Total Estimated Investment | $95,000 |
These figures are illustrative, not a quote for a particular restoration. Actual expenses vary substantially with condition, labor rates, restoration scope, and parts requirements.
Now consider purchasing a completed classic Mustang that is already in attractive, road-ready condition.
Depending on the model and condition, purchasing an existing restoration may save thousands of dollars and eliminate months or years of waiting.
However, a finished vehicle still deserves a thorough inspection. Attractive paint does not automatically mean quality workmanship underneath.
Our recommendation: Before taking on a major Mustang restoration project, compare the complete projected cost against professionally restored examples currently available for sale.
You may be surprised at the difference.
5. Are Classic Ford Mustangs Good Investments?
Classic Mustangs have a long-established collector following, making them attractive to enthusiasts interested in vehicles that can offer both driving enjoyment and potential value retention.
However, not every classic Mustang appreciates, and no collector vehicle is a guaranteed financial investment.
Several factors can influence value:
Originality: Factory configurations and verified original equipment may appeal to collectors.
Engine: Desirable V8 combinations and documented performance engines can influence pricing.
Body Style: Fastbacks, Convertibles, and Coupes can have very different market values.
Condition: Rust-free structure, quality paint, and sound mechanical components are important.
Documentation: Original paperwork, restoration receipts, and vehicle history can increase buyer confidence.
Rarity: Genuine factory performance variants may command premiums.
Market Demand: Auction results and comparable sales help establish realistic values.
Valuation resources such as JD Power and Hagerty can provide useful reference points, but values should always be compared with recent sales of similar vehicles.
For many collectors, the greatest return comes from the enjoyment of owning and driving a piece of American automotive history.
6. Classic Ford Mustangs for Sale at Thiel Motor Sales
Looking for a classic Mustang of your own?
Thiel Motor Sales regularly offers an exciting selection of restored, original, and modified Ford Mustangs.
Here are several examples recently advertised at our dealership.
1965 Ford Mustang Convertible — $39,997
VIEW OUR 1965 MUSTANG CONVERTIBLE
1965 Ford Mustang 2+2 Fastback — $59,997
VIEW OUR 1965 MUSTANG FASTBACK
1966 Ford Mustang Convertible — $44,997
VIEW OUR 1966 MUSTANG CONVERTIBLE
1970 Ford Mustang Fastback — Boss 302 Tribute — $62,997
Iconic 1970 Fastback styling
Boss 302 tribute appearance
347 cubic-inch Stroker V8
5-speed manual transmission
Air conditioning
VIEW OUR 1970 MUSTANG FASTBACK
Prices and availability are subject to change. Visit the individual vehicle listings for current information.
7. What Should You Look for When Buying a Classic Mustang?
Before purchasing a 1965–1973 Ford Mustang, consider the following:
Inspect for Rust: Pay close attention to the floor pans, rocker panels, frame rails, cowl area, trunk, and other structural components.
Verify the Drivetrain: Check engine identification numbers, transmission information, and vehicle documentation when originality matters.
Review the Restoration: Look for quality bodywork, proper panel alignment, clean wiring, and evidence of professional workmanship.
Check Mechanical Condition: Inspect the braking system, suspension, steering, cooling system, and drivetrain.
Compare Actual Market Values: Review comparable vehicles and recent auction results before making a purchasing decision.
Buy From an Experienced Dealer: Working with a dealership familiar with classic and collector vehicles can simplify the purchasing process, particularly for out-of-state customers.
8. Frequently Asked Questions About Classic Ford Mustangs
What is the most collectible year of Ford Mustang?
There is no single answer. Early Fastbacks, desirable Convertibles, Shelby models, Boss Mustangs, and certain factory performance configurations all attract collector attention. Condition and authenticity are critical.
Are 1965 and 1966 Mustangs good classic cars to own?
Yes. Their iconic styling, broad parts availability, and enthusiastic owner community make them popular choices for classic-car enthusiasts.
Is it cheaper to restore or buy an already-restored Mustang?
For many buyers, purchasing an already-restored Mustang can be more economical than commissioning a major professional restoration. However, the answer depends on the vehicle's purchase price, condition, and restoration requirements.
Can I finance a classic Ford Mustang?
Yes! Thiel Motor Sales offers nationwide financing options for qualified buyers purchasing eligible classic and collector vehicles.
Can I buy a Mustang from Thiel Motor Sales if I live outside Iowa?
Absolutely! We work with classic-car enthusiasts throughout the United States and can assist with nationwide vehicle shipping arrangements.
Find Your Dream Mustang at Thiel Motor Sales!
For more than six decades, the Ford Mustang has represented American performance, style, and freedom.
Whether you're searching for an original Mustang Coupe, a beautifully restored Convertible, or a powerful Fastback, these legendary automobiles continue to capture the attention of collectors nationwide.
At Thiel Motor Sales Inc., we believe buying a classic car should be an exciting and enjoyable experience.
As a third-generation, family-owned dealership established in 1972, we're proud to help enthusiasts find the classic vehicles they've always dreamed of owning.
SHOP OUR CLASSIC CAR INVENTORY TODAY!
WWW.THIELMOTORS.COM — VIEW OUR CURRENT INVENTORY
THIEL MOTOR SALES INC.
Classic • Collector • Muscle • Unique
Family Owned & Operated Since 1972
DeWitt, Iowa — Our 1-and-ONLY Location!
CALL: 563-659-9309
Nationwide Financing • Worldwide Shipping
YOUR NEXT CLASSIC IS WAITING AT THIEL MOTOR SALES!